Child-Killer Samir Kuntar Honored in Syria

The man who smashed a four-year-old girl's head on coastal rocks is hailed as a hero.

November 26, 2008 - by P. David Hornik
<- Prev  Page 2 of 2

Also getting in on the act was Palestinian Authority president and much-lauded, purported moderate Mahmoud Abbas, who sent greetings to Kuntar as his Fatah party organized a rally in Ramallah to celebrate Kuntar’s release and the return of the remains of a legendary Palestinian female terrorist. That wasn’t enough for Abbas, who in late August met with Kuntar in Beirut during a visit to Lebanon.

Though Kuntar’s treatment since being freed is just one, if perhaps particularly striking, small detail in the Arab world’s anti-Israeli ethos, it offers a convenient dividing line between two mindsets on Israel’s conflict with the Arabs. On one side are those who take note of the lionization of this child-killer, talk about it and write about it, feel shocked and that it perhaps even goes beyond their already dim expectations.

On the other side are those for whom it makes no difference — not even the fact that both extreme figures like the Hezbollah minister and Syrian dictator Assad, and moderate or reputedly moderate figures like Siniora and Abbas, take part in glorifying Kuntar as a hero and a model.

For instance, for Brent Scowcroft and Zbigniew Brzezinski in the Washington Post last Friday, “the current situation is such that the opportunity for success [in Israeli-Palestinian peacemaking] has never been greater.” But for veteran peace processor Aaron David Miller in an article two days later, “a conflict-ending agreement between Israelis and Palestinians may no longer be possible. … I would … suggest to President-elect Barack Obama … that he recognize there’s no deal in this negotiation now. … Instead, go all-out for an Israeli-Syrian agreement. ”

Among the optimists on the Syrian tack count also part of the Israeli defense establishment, which believes Assad can be lured out of his deep enmeshment in the terror axis with the Golan Heights and other Western favors. As for outgoing Israeli prime minister Ehud Olmert, after living most of his life as a skeptical hawk he now sees peace sprouting all over and is an enthusiast of both the Palestinian and Syrian tacks.

It’s true that Israel signed a peace treaty three decades back with Sadat of Egypt; he lost his life for it soon after, and today Egypt is an epicenter of anti-Semitism and Sinai is — under Cairo’s at best neglectful eye — a smuggling route for the ever-mounting Hamas war on Israel from Gaza. It’s also true Israel has an important, stabilizing peace with the Jordanian government, while the population remains among the most anti-Semitic in the world.

And when it comes to Syria and the Palestinians, the territories in question — the Golan and the West Bank, respectively — are of even greater security significance than Gaza, whose loss has meant daily rocket fire on southern Israel.

But for the unflappable peace-mongers, Israel can’t hand over the Golan and the West Bank, as well, to the Kuntar-admirers too soon; some of us aren’t that stupid.

<- Prev  Page 2 of 2

P. David Hornik is a freelance writer and translator living in Tel Aviv. He blogs at http://pdavidhornik.typepad.com/

Bookmark and Share
Email Print Podcasts Digg PJM Home

Pajamas Media appreciates your comments that abide by the following guidelines:

1. Avoid profanities or foul language unless it is contained in a necessary quote or is relevant to the comment.

2. Stay on topic.

3. Disagree, but avoid ad hominem attacks.

4. Threats are treated seriously and reported to law enforcement.

5. Spam and advertising are not permitted in the comments area.

The clause regarding "hate speech" has been deleted because readers criticized it as being too loosely defined. We agreed.

These guidelines are very general and cannot cover every possible situation. Please don't assume that Pajamas Media management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment. We reserve the right to filter or delete comments or to deny posting privileges entirely at our discretion. If you feel your comment was filtered inappropriately, please email us at story@pajamasmedia.com.

13 Comments

1. suztours:

You, Mr. Hornik, aren’t that stupid; I’m not that stupid. But it seems that some “stupid” virus has infected our so-called leaders here in Israel and in the United States as well as right ’round the world when it comes to Israel doing anything that could actually be in its favor!

I was against releasing Kuntar as well as any body swap. And I’m not alone at all here in Israel, where we do want our sons & daughters here with us and not murdered by those who hate us but not at any price. Many friends who are required to serve in “milium” (reserve army duty) have signed waivers releasing the government from negotiating for the return of their bodies should they be kidnapped by Hezb’Allah or Hamas or any other terror organization or state.

Nov 26, 2008 - 4:28 am 2. Jeffrey:

They truely disgrace themselves.

Nov 26, 2008 - 4:51 am 3. Lilith:

Revolting.

Nov 26, 2008 - 8:42 am 4. Sam:

Any person, society, or culture who honors a child killer as a national hero and symbol of the ‘resistance’ is morally bankrupt, reprehensible, and lets face it, intellectually bereft. Just a sad state of affairs, that people would applaud this kind of action. Axis of Evil? For once, nail on the freaking head W.

Nov 26, 2008 - 9:55 am 5. DavidN:

Yeah, but the Axis of Evil was Iraq, Iran, and North Korea…no Syria involved. And not to put too fine a point on it, a child-killer wouldn’t be feted in any country in the Middle East. Unfortunately, most Arabs don’t consider Jews people, so the label doesn’t apply here, as far as they’re concerned.

Nov 26, 2008 - 11:26 am 6. Forcheville:

Dr Assad spoke more truly than he thought in saying of Kuntar that he is “a symbol of the struggle for freedom across the Arab world and the whole world.”
Expect his face to soon appear on t-shirts, a sort of Arab Che, de rigeur at hipper than thou Columbia parties.
He’s also a perfect vehicle for Hollywood treatment, maybe Oliver Stone is already optioning him.

Nov 26, 2008 - 12:04 pm 7. SeanLA:

I don’t know, watching a movie like Platoon and you see American heros killing lots of children,

John Kerry even spoke of it.

In the recent HBO series Generation Kill you see the American Heros killing children every episode, every single episode the US Heros kill women and children, theres even one segment when a child survives a shooting and is denied help from the Hero leader.

Obama said it himself, US Heros are bombing women and children.

What else would you expect? With all that I wouldn’t expect anything less than a child killer being celebrated as such.

Nov 26, 2008 - 3:05 pm 8. cedarford:

suztours – Well said.

I was against releasing Kuntar as well as any body swap. And I’m not alone at all here in Israel, where we do want our sons & daughters here with us and not murdered by those who hate us but not at any price. Many friends who are required to serve in “milium” (reserve army duty) have signed waivers releasing the government from negotiating for the return of their bodies should they be kidnapped by Hezb’Allah or Hamas or any other terror organization or state.

Hard to single out Muslim leaders for “allowing Kuntar and 199 others to celebrate” when it was pandering Israeli politicians that decreed it was worth releasing 200 of the worst terrorists to celebrate away – so they could get 2 corpses back from Hez.

Like it or not, but commando raids, even those by the USA, have involved killing civilians that were in the way or could betray commando’s position. Medal of Honor winner Bob Kerrey ordered Vietnamese civilians – old men, even kids – shot, stabbed, clubbed to death on raids. We – I guess – compensated by awarding the Medal of Honor to a green SEAL lieutenant who spared 2 civilians and got himself, 2 members of his Squad, and 19 rescuers – all fellow SEALS or AF spec ops killed (the biggest one-engagement Spec Ops bloodbath since WWII) when the civilians he spared put a force of over 100 AQ and Taliban directly on top of the 4-man deep deep behind enemy lines.

In a raid behind enemy lines, commandos know that not only is death likely in their own cases, but civilians they encounter may have to be whacked – even the old, woman, kids.

When I was in the service, I made it clear to my men we weren’t a Spec Ops outfit bound by Code to “leave no man behind”…That I would not ask anyone to trade or risk their life for a corpse, only self-volunteers would be in such jeopardy. We didn’t think of “no trades for body tissue for live enemy” because I don’t think the US has ever capitulated like the Israelis did freeing 200 terrorists for two dead bodies – it never entered our discussion.

Sam:
Any person, society, or culture who honors a child killer as a national hero and symbol of the ‘resistance’ is morally bankrupt, reprehensible, and lets face it, intellectually bereft. Just a sad state of affairs, that people would applaud this kind of action. Axis of Evil? For once, nail on the freaking head W

Besides Kerrey, the label “child killer” could be applied to McCain, 1 in 70 of our initial military personnel invading Iraq, plus most WWII bombers.
Most honored by our government for doing so. Even face-to-face.
Generally, the Arab governments realize Israel was guilty of huge weakness freeing Kuntar and a couple hundred others for bones..and “honor ceremonies” are their way of rubbing it in and enraging Israelis against not just them, but Israel’s craven leaders…

Nov 26, 2008 - 3:43 pm 9. Anonymous:

Bashar Assad is a very evil beast, who has money for himself, while the Syrian people are suffering very bad. Samir Kuntar is another very evil beast.

Nov 26, 2008 - 4:34 pm 10. Abhor Gore:

“Assad feted him on Monday”.

OBAMA: “Kuntar, Assad! Come on over and “chat”…I’m meeting with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinijad, too, so we’ll all have SO much to talk about. Perhaps a spot of tea at the house of my (wink wink) “neighbor who I know from the block” Billy Ayers? Aw, c’mon…Khalidi will be there, too! He is so looking forward to meeting you! (But no cameras, please!) I think you all would get along just FABULOUSLY! OR, we could do something REALLY naughty…..How would you like to come to my church and preach about hate and racism? You’d feel right at home! You and Rev. Wright would just be BFFs forever! One big happy terrorist family! Now everyone hold hands and sing kumbaya while I run the nation into the toilet!

NEXT STOP: TONY RESKO’S HOUSE where we will be sharing marxist quotes, reading up on socialism and trading ideas on how to best circumvent the intent of the Constitution and practice “sleight of hand” tricks to use on the stupid Americans. Psst….Keep this on the down low, but most of those dummies were the ones who got me elected!”

(Uproarious laughter in the background erupts)

Nov 26, 2008 - 7:10 pm 11. Jersey Dave:

SeanLA: “John Kerry even spoke on it.”

Yes, he lied on his fellow soldiers. While the North Vietnamese at the Hanoi Hilton were carrying out real atrocities.

There is also a difference between uniformed soldiers and un-uniformed brigands under the laws of war.

The problem with the terrorists is, someone in the west goes out of line at somewhere like Abu Gharib, we punish them – and rightly so. When one of the terrorists goes and does worse stuff, they don’t condemn them, they make them heroes. We have the ability to do a lot of things but they have a fanatical nature and don’t care what they do. It is their lack of capability relative to us that means they haven’t done more. We need to understand that.

Saddam and the Taliban butchered many thousands of their own people in Iraq and Afghainstan. The majorities there support their new democratically elected governments. The terrorists aim to murder and oppress. The US aims to liberate and help free peoples.

It is a difference that is forgotten at our perils. Had these enemies the opportunities to butcher us, they would not care who we voted for or what we believed. They kill and terrorize, period. It is all they know and all they do. It is easier to destroy than to build.

We are builders. The terrorists fear their own people becoming that, so they keep them ignorant and steal aid money and such from them and tell them it is all everyone else’s fault but theirs.

Nov 27, 2008 - 8:13 pm 12. kimcliftrn:

Assignation is the only word I could say for a man that could kill a 4 year old girl.

Dec 1, 2008 - 8:32 am 13. tanstaafl:

It was a big deal for Nasrallah/Hezbollah to spring the “widely respected” Kuntar (gagging with maggots) and other criminals from Israeli jails.

Whoever they are (Hezbollah…Hamas) springing their Islamist guys from the jails of the “zionist entity” is always an important goal.

I’m sure, every time one of these springing deals (as in Kuntar) is “successful”, it is another positive notch in the determination of Israel’s avowed enemies to the north and west.

Dec 2, 2008 - 8:01 am

Write a Comment

Name: (required, displayed)
Email: (required, not publicized)
URL: (optional, displayed)
Comments: