My OFA (Organizing for Astroturfing) Adventure

The author finds little activist energy for ObamaCare in southwestern Ohio.

August 14, 2009 - by Tom Blumer
Page 1 of 2  Next ->

I hope the establishment media is monitoring and interested in reporting the real results of the attempt by Organizing for Astroturfing, er, America, to lobby individual members of Congress to support ObamaCare. Sadly, I doubt they are.

If what I have learned this week holds elsewhere, it will turn out to have been a complete bust and will demonstrate that, despite attempts to make it appear otherwise, there is no grassroots groundswell for statist health care.

* * *

On Sunday evening, I received a compelling email that I simply could not ignore calling me to action (click here to see a graphic of the full email):

All throughout August, our members of Congress are back in town. Insurance companies and partisan attack groups are stirring up fear with false rumors about the president’s plan, and it’s extremely important that folks like you speak up now.

So we’ve cooked up an easy, powerful way for you to make a big impression: Office Visits for Health Reform.

All this week, OFA members like you will be stopping by local congressional offices to show our support for insurance reform.

Sign up now to visit Rep. Jean Schmidt’s office in Cincinnati this week.

Well, as a bona fide, long-ago signed-up “member” of Organizing for Astroturfing, er, America, I could not turn down such an important request. (Never mind that the email refers to “health reform” and “insurance reform,” which, last time I checked, are different things.)

So I went to the OFA website and found this sign-up form (red box at link added by me). It informed me of the 2nd District Republican’s office hours, address, and phone number, and asked me to select a time to visit. You’ll notice that the form also required me to provide my phone number, “so that an organizer can follow up with you.” How thoughtful.

Separately, in keeping with the spirit of the OFA email, I “cooked up” the idea of also visiting the office of 1st District Rep. Steve Driehaus, whose district’s boundary is about ten miles away from the BizzyBlog bunker. Driehaus is, at least in theory, one of the “on the fence” Blue Dog Democrats. At an August 4 town hall meeting that made national news, he got an earful from those opposed to the plan and told those who attended that he hasn’t decided how he will vote. Thus, Driehaus is a guy OFA should be targeting.

I made a commitment to visit Schmidt’s office at 4:00 p.m. on Monday, August 10, and to visit Driehaus at 3:00 p.m. In each case, I received a confirming email response that also directed me to a two-page “Office Visits for Health Reform Guide” (PDF).

As you’ll see, the guide has a few amazing claims, with no sourcing, about “the cost of inaction in Ohio”:

  • 1,500,000 are uninsured today in Ohio and 1,180 Ohioans will lose their health coverage every week because of rising costs.
  • The average family premium in Ohio costs $1,000 more because our system fails to cover everyone.
  • Our broken health insurance system will cost the Ohio economy as much as $7.1 billion this year in productivity losses due to lack of coverage.

I did my own sourcing and determined that the claims are either flat-out wrong or squishy deceptions.

Page 1 of 2  Next ->

Tom Blumer owns a training and development company based in Mason, Ohio, outside of Cincinnati. He presents personal finance-related workshops and speeches at companies, and runs BizzyBlog.com.

Bookmark and Share
Email Print Podcasts Digg PJM Home

Pajamas Media appreciates your comments that abide by the following guidelines:

1. Avoid profanities or foul language unless it is contained in a necessary quote or is relevant to the comment.

2. Stay on topic.

3. Disagree, but avoid ad hominem attacks.

4. Threats are treated seriously and reported to law enforcement.

5. Spam and advertising are not permitted in the comments area.

The clause regarding "hate speech" has been deleted because readers criticized it as being too loosely defined. We agreed.

These guidelines are very general and cannot cover every possible situation. Please don't assume that Pajamas Media management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment. We reserve the right to filter or delete comments or to deny posting privileges entirely at our discretion. If you feel your comment was filtered inappropriately, please email us at story@pajamasmedia.com.

22 Comments

1. Chris:

Oh, of course the guardians of our democracy will report the facts!

Ever since Dan Rather got to the truth about those memos he was sold he’s been the lead man at CBS!

Ever since Katie Couric gave Joe Biden the same level of “gotcha” grilling she gave to Sarah Palin she’s been a model of journalistic ethics!

/sarcasm off

While a few cracks in the facade have started the leg-thrill media are still in puppy love with Obama and are fatally attracted to his socialist agenda.

Aug 14, 2009 - 4:28 am 2. Libertyship46:

Makes sense. Any person supporting the president is part of a “grass roots” organization that is exercising their constitutional right to free speech. Anybody disagreeing with the president is part of a “mob,” “un-American,” an “evil-monger” or worse, a “Nazi.” Reid, Pelosi, and Obama should all be ashamed of themselves. It’s actually kind of funny, though, that the original community organizer, Obama, is now upset that the community is organizing against him. What a coward and a fraud. You get what you vote for, America. For all those lovely liberals and independents that put this lowlife into office, please remember that it was your childish belief in “Hope and Change” that got us to this point, rather than looking at a person’s entire record and list of actual accomplishments (not to mention the people he associates with, such as the Reverend Wright or Bill Ayers, to name a few). The only thing now is to stand up and be heard.

We must now make a decision, you and I. Like the great Colonel Joshua Chamberlain commanding the 20th Maine at the Battle of Gettysburg, it is time for Americans to make a stand. Chamberlain and a handful of men saved the Union at Gettysburg during the Battle of the Little Round Top by standing firm and not allowing the rebel forces to advance any further. Now it’s time for another handful of Americans to save the Union by protesting against what Obama wants to do to this country. Stand up, America. Write to your elected officials. Show up at town meetings and make yourself heard. Contribute to blogs whenever you see some left-wing garbage being printed and point out the lies and inconsistencies in liberal propaganda. And, most important, vote out of office anybody who supports this socialist healthcare bill and support any candidate, in either party, that actually wants some fiscal responsibility and the elimination of the pork that has tainted and corrupted the entire federal government. Only by actually making your voice heard can we stop complete socialism from taking over this nation. If Chamberlain could stand up for what he believed in, so can you. We don’t have much time left and the issue is still in doubt, but you can make a difference. After all, Chamberlain had to face Confederate bullets. All we have to face are the SEIU thugs, MoveOn.org, Media Matters, the AFL-CIO, the trial lawyers, and about every other union and illegal alien out there. But if Chamberlain could stand tall and succeed, so can we.

Aug 14, 2009 - 4:34 am 3. Tennessee:

As a former Cincy guy who went to LaSalle HS (the vaunted Lancers) and hated Elder, Steve Driehaus, the congressman and Elder grad, ought to be ashamed.

Aug 14, 2009 - 4:40 am 4. AThinkingPerson:

Libertyship46: Well said! The “All we have to face” part was a bit daunting but unfortunately true. It is an awesome sight to see everyday patriots choosing to take part in the town halls. I am full of hope for the future of this country that there ARE still people willing to take a stand for the greater good and not fall for an oppressive regime.

Aug 14, 2009 - 5:50 am 5. The Grey Man:

Wow, a Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain reference. I’m apparently not the only one who reads history. Our position is more akin to John Mosby at Miskel’s Farm. We may have been caught unprepared, but if we hang tough and fight as fiercely, we can be victorious.

Aug 14, 2009 - 6:18 am 6. macko:

I rec’d the same email and sent it to flag@whitehouse.gov

Aug 14, 2009 - 6:19 am 7. Herr Morgenholz:

What? No visit to Mike Turner, the 3rd District Repub who voted for SCHIP and for the god-awful Food Safety and Farm Tyranny bill? He’s a squish and should be sentenced to several hours of Goldwater and Reagan speeches. He also doesnt return phone calls or emails, so at least he’s as arrogant as one would expect from a RINO.

Aug 14, 2009 - 7:02 am 8. Marica:

I admit, I had to re-read the first couple of paragraphs; I was experiencing some cognitive dissidence. Why didn’t I get this email? I am a member of OFA: Ohio Freedom Alliance. From the Mission statement:

The Ohio Freedom Alliance is a diverse group of Ohio residents who have come together to preserve and protect liberty in America as it was originally intended by our founding fathers. Members of the OFA are from all different demographics and political affiliations. The Ohio Freedom Alliance was founded in order to facilitate greater communication and cooperation between various freedom-minded individuals and organizations. Our intention is not to replace or dilute the efforts of existing organizations, but rather unite all freedom-minded individuals and groups. Through this network of OFA affiliated individuals and groups, we can all be more effective together than we can be alone.

I know there are only 26 letters available for acronyms, but I found this co-incidence curious.

Aug 14, 2009 - 7:20 am 9. Roux:

They aren’t going to protest unless they get paid. They don’t vote unless there is some benefit in it for them personally.

ACORN has its’ roots in New Orleans style politics where politicians pay the alphabet soup organizations for endorsements. The money is used for “get out the vote” drives or as we call it “walkin’ around money”. Former Governor Edwin Edwards (currently in Federal Prison), former Congressman William “Dollar Bill” Jefferson (just convicted and soon joining EWE) and Senator for life Mary Landrieu are experts in this field.

Without the “walkin’ around money” these people don’t care about much.

Aug 14, 2009 - 7:28 am 10. twiga:

Libertyship46: Yowzah! That was bracing morning reading. Chamberlain is indeed an inspirational figure; so is Gen. MacAuliffe at Bastogne, saying “Nuts!”

Aug 14, 2009 - 7:39 am 11. Joe C.:

Don’t take ANY of these “studies” at face value!

The IOM said in a 2002 report (“Care
Without Coverage: Too Little, Too
Late”) that 18,314 die each year due to a lack of preventive services, a timely diagnosis or appropriate care; then attributed lack of insurance as the sole cause for this. It was assumed that the insured and uninsured populations were exactly the same, which we know that they’re not — especially from 1971-1987 from which the data was taken– and no other behavioral characteristics or structural barriers as causes were considered.

This laughable back-of an-envelope methodology was based on old studies and 15-30 year old data (at the time), which is summarized here: http://www.urban.org/UploadedPDF/411588_uninsured_dying.pdf . Then this study was subsequently bastardized by The Urban Institute (and Families USA) into reports-cum-press releases of their own. This then became the basis for the 2003 study you reference.

Aug 14, 2009 - 8:18 am 12. Saltherring:

What, a shortage of outraged, “grass roots” Obamacare advocates? I guess Soros will have to get his checkbook out and bus some ACORN-types in! Or perhaps all the leftists’ “usual suspects” were at work that day…HA! More likely playing video games or scamming some government agency for free college tuition. I thought the Dimocrats were better organized?

Aug 14, 2009 - 8:18 am 13. fiona:

With a group, I attended a MoveOn.org demo at Sen. Bill Nelson’s office – with our handlettered opposition signs. I noticed that our group went INTO the office and left handwritten messages with our home addresses on them for the Senator. The MoveOn group did not – maybe because they were not actually Florida voters? or even legally in the country.

We outnumbered them by a few and were better mannered too. We managed to put this together, signs and all, with less than 24 hours notice. We get the notifications from the MoveOn or other pro Obama groups, make our signs and turn out. Be sure and arrive early if you go to one of these demos and take pictures of the busses being unloaded – it is often done in a far corner of the parking lot.

Smile and counter chants with facts – it drives them crazy, since all they have is slogans and many don’t even understand them. Every once in a while you encounter a couple of moderates caught up by friends – you can make some headway there with reasonable arguments and facts.

Aug 14, 2009 - 8:35 am 14. Linda Gee:

Among Democrat HR Honorable Members, has the White House instituted a two-track system for Congressional office visits, town halls, and conference calls, with a fast track for registered Organizing for America visitors and a slow track for everyone else? A number of us here in Marin County have been trying to talk sense about Obamacare to Lynn Woolsey, head of the Progressive Caucus — like talking to a brick wall, but worth the effort. She isn’t having any town hall meetings. Instead, she held a conference call that was not announced on her website, despite requests for information. People must have been able to register for this call in advance, but who and how? When I visited her office in person, the staffer asked me point-blank if I was from Organizing for America. Do other readers have reasons to suspect that this two track system might exist? How can we compare notes and reach a reasonable conclusion?

Aug 14, 2009 - 9:01 am 15. ic:

9. Roux:
“They aren’t going to protest unless they get paid. They don’t vote unless there is some benefit in it for them personally.”

Don’t you worry, when the price is right they will show up. ACORN has hundreds of millions earmarked to stimulate them. The money of those who are against Obamacare is earmarked to those who “support” Obamacare. In Los Angelos, the going price is $10-15/hr. joining the astroturd, er, I mean astroturf.

From an acorn grows an oak tree; from ACORN grows AstroTurd.

Aug 14, 2009 - 10:56 am 16. Carl Gordon:

I think what is needed is some clarity…

A half-wit Glen Beck enthusiast with an exquisite feel for irony but lacking the self-awareness to detect it in himself intercepts covert idiotic radio and television messages and uncovers archived secrets and scandals of deceitful proportions, this, as the moderator intones “Some times you just have to believe in something, even if it isn’t true!”. Aghast, he goes next door to his WASP neighbor, cautiously excited, as the aforementioned was a over-medicated GOP precinct worker whom the teabagger enthusiast wanted friendship of. The lanky, thick-skulled, pie-eyed neighbor is slumped over the imported compressed sawdust dining room table, poisoned just thirty seconds before by his wife, just home from target practice, who most likely already knew of the patriotic enthusiast’s forthcoming revelations. A prickly line of sweat covers the enthusiast’s forehead now, as the realization hits him that the same pundits and other agitators him and his now brain-dead compatriots once cowered before and backed and talked of in hushed tones, have tricked him into their war against himself and the very same comrades, whom, through the years, the enthusiast and brain-dead supporters would have wished torture upon each other. A dick-less peon of the patriot walks in and casually assaults the Glen Beck fan in his kitchen for murder and sedition against the government. The mad bitch swings crazily to the enthusiast’s left side, towards his new dental work, while briefly remembering that his mother was a helicopter dust-off operator and had a large black dog. Just as a wild roundhouse whizzes by is left temple, the alcoholic lemming-like imbecile drops to his knees, almost punching his own unit and flings a can that was crammed in his pocket onto the lawn, littered with previously deposited cans of spud-free Lackey, an alcohol-free lager. A grime-smeared full sized Chevy pick-up truck is parked outside, with pro-nicotine pro-nuclear crap on the side panels. I digress however; The mad kid, two days before, had just got back from a backwoods cookie party, catered by the same quasi-religious zealots and Pharma-corporation manipulators. He had his black horse-hair coat, and a black party archbishop’s hat with three bars for a skull-and-crossbones. And this day he looked like the victim of a pogrom.

Aug 14, 2009 - 11:28 am 17. Sapwolf:

I’ll be at the Recess Rally at Schmidt’s office on the 22nd. With my camera, ready to take a thumping by SEIU goons.

My dream is to get a post beating interview with Megyn Kelly on Fox News. Now that’s astroturfing you can believe in.

Aug 14, 2009 - 12:13 pm 18. Marc Malone:

Nice bit of gumshoe-work, Blumer. Very nice. Very revealing.

I wonder what the receptionit’s response would have been if you had asked to see his schedule for the day you were there? I wonder what it looked like? Oh, not in today… or ever? Let us know if you ever get a meeting. After all, you made the effort to show up and to pay for parking. It’s not like a ton of people showed up. The least the Congresscritter could do would be to give you a quick call.

Aug 14, 2009 - 12:32 pm 19. Steve:

I have been calling and E-mailing Driehaus for the last couple of weeks and today I received another Demo talking point answer. He votes the way the leadership tells him to. Let’s make him a one term congressman, and take away their lifetime pensions also.

Aug 14, 2009 - 3:05 pm 20. Midwesterner:

CAP’s alleged average national per-family premium addition due to uninsured care is $1,100; Ohio’s average is $1,000. CAP naively assumes that every dollar of care provided for free is automatically added to premiums.

From Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health:
http://www.jhsph.edu/publichealthnews/press_releases/2007/anderson_hospital_charges.html

Hospitals collect about 39% of what they bill cash (uninsured) customers but they bill them over three times as much as Medicare customers pay. That’s right. Hospitals actually collect almost 120% from the uninsured as an entire group compared to what they collect for the same services provided to Medicare patients. Hospitals actually only collect a couple of percent less from the uninsured as a group than they do from the insured as a group for the same services. It is Medicare/Medicaid that freeload off of both the insured and uninsured groups’ payments. The insurance industry is doing their best to claim a cost where none exists and the hospitals are trying to keep their actual non-losses on uninsured out of the public eye.

The uninsured cash customers are just a innocent scape goat for what the industry wants to do for its own reasons.

Aug 14, 2009 - 6:56 pm 21. Tom Blumer:

#20, thank you for that additional info.

I also heard during the week from a talk-show caller that hospitals collect 130% or so from the insured, about 94% from Medicare, and 86% from Medicaid (last two may be flipped).

I think it’s fair to say that a lot of what hospitals collect for services to the uninsured comes directly from state and local governments already, and is NOT included directly or indirectly in the premiums of the insured.

Aug 15, 2009 - 5:54 am 22. Lynn B:

I went to a hospital in Cleveland. I paid in the emergency room BEFORE treatment was done and paid when the fifteen stitches came out BEFORE I saw a doctor. I received a bill for the balance and paid that too. I chose not to use medical insurance.

Aug 17, 2009 - 3:24 pm