The Rosett Report

Support Pajamas Media; Visit Our Advertisers

I was doing some traveling over the weekend, with connecting flights through Chicago’s O’Hare, and during what seems to be the routinely scheduled five-hour O’Hare delay, decided to kill some time browsing the magazine racks – with their displays replicated in one terminal after another of this major hub of American airborne gridlock. Looking out from row upon row of the racks were covers devoted to the two women most prominent in the presidential campaign, now that Hillary, with a salute to the pantsuit set, has left the stage to the ladies in heels.

Here’s what jumped out:

There were two covers showing Sarah Palin. One was Time, “The Education of Sarah Palin.” The other was the already much-commented upon cover of Us, showing Palin holding her newborn son, stamped with the headline: “Babies, Lies and Scandal.”

That second Palin cover was paired in main displays with OK magazine’s cover showing Michelle and Barack Obama and their two daughters, a happy frolicking family; headline: “Life With My Girls.”

There were another four covers showing Michelle Obama. On the cover of “Upscale” (which has as its slogan, “Living the Affluent Lifestyle), with a story about Michelle as a powerful force who will never lie to her husband. On the cover of ”Ladies Home Journal” hugging Barack, headlined: “Barack and Michelle Obama/Why he calls her his chief adviser and what jolts him awake at 3 A.M.” On the cover of Ebony, headlined ”The Real Michelle Obama. The First Lady Hopeful Talks Family, Fidelity & the Future of America.” On the cover of Essence, yet another in the series of magazine stories on the idyll: “At Home With the Obama Family.”

There’s no law — nor should there be — that says magazines have to be fair. But there’s also no law that says anyone has to buy this stuff. My advice, if transit O’Hare you must: bring a book.

Comment DiggDigg This Delicious del.icio.us Digg Print Digg PJM Home

5 Comments

1. Jake in Pittsburgh:

Another Palin coup…

Many (most? all?) of the lifestyle magazines are targeted toward women. What do they see? Palin is belittled and the Obamas are coronated.

And readers of those magazines are certainly picking up on it.

Sep 8, 2008 - 7:35 am 2. Jake in Pittsburgh:

Another Palin coup…

Many (most? nearly all?) of the readers of the lifestyle magazines are women. Regardless of policital leanings, women will see how Palin has been slammed and the Obamas elevated. (This is why the Oprah story resonates, at least a bit, as well.)

Maybe some media groups will try to remediate that, but the damage is done.

Sep 8, 2008 - 7:46 am 3. JI:

Bring your own book, that is the answer.

The main stream media, including the magazines, have now outed themselves and proved to everyone that their reporting is unreliable.

This is sure to augment the declines in circulation and revenue that they are all experiencing and will drive more people to the internet in search of balanced information.

Governor Palin has done more than unite the Republicans, she has also caused the media to jump naked off the Golden Gate Bridge and I don’t think they can swim.

Sep 9, 2008 - 6:52 am 4. knickerbocker:

I agree with what’s been said here. Let’s not forget that “authenticity” was one of the election’s buzzwords early on even before “gamechanger.” Palin’s got it; Michelle doesn’t.

Sep 12, 2008 - 8:18 am 5. Marion L:

It is not the fault of news magazines that Michelle Obama is a happy, accomplished woman with a happy family life.

Nor is it the fault of news magazines that Sarah Palin is not experienced enough to be vice president of the United States. When asked by Katie Couric to name one Supreme Court decision other than Roe v Wade, she was silent. That is but one example of why even some conservatives such as George Will are writing that it was a mistake for McCain to choose Palin as his running mate.

Oct 4, 2008 - 7:33 pm

Write a Comment

Name: (required, displayed)
Email: (required, not publicized)
URL: (optional, displayed)
remember personal info?
Comments: