The Rosett Report

Support Pajamas Media; Visit Our Advertisers

As Russian troops loot, shoot and roll short-range missiles into Georgia, surely UN tradition calls for the Secretary-General to protest this invasion of sovereign territory tooth and nail? That, of course, is what Kofi Annan did when America led a coalition to invade Iraq — after Iraq’s tyranny had defied 17 UN resolutions, flagrantly violated UN sanctions, kicked out UN weapons inspectors, corrupted the UN’s own Security Council and racked up a history of gassing its own people, filling mass graves, consorting with terrorists, and started two wars by invading two neighboring states.

In Iraq’s case, the UN had such over-riding concern for territorial integrity that in the UN calculus, all Saddam Hussein’s violations, abuses, corruption and atrocities paled next to the priorities summed up by Annan’s denunciation of the invasion as “illegal.”

One could argue (and I have) that in making this pronouncement, Kofi Annan was wrong, hypocritical, and way out of line. But if the UN cherishes such benchmarks of illegality, then surely Russia’s invasion of Georgia should right now be inspiring strident cries of “illegal” from the global fraternity at Turtle Bay?

Uh… well, let’s see. Last Wednesday, Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon did reiterate his “support for a solution based on the full respect of the territorial integrity and sovereignty of Georgia” — but he did it while urging acceptance of an EU-brokered peace plan that goes disturbingly light on that same territorial integrity. On Thursday, according to the UN, Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon voiced “deep concern at the humanitarian impact of the Georgian conflict.” On Saturday, Ban conferred with advisers and diplomats.

This Monday, finally getting to the heart of the matter, Ban’s Secretariat swung into action, doing what the UN really knows how to do – ask for money: “UN seeking nearly $59 million to aid Georgian conflict victims.”

Meanwhile, over at the Security Council, progress on the defense of Georgia’s territorial integrity was neatly summed up by a recent Wall Street Journal headline: “UN Security Council Fails to Meet Over the Weekend.”

Not that the Security Council hasn’t been trying. Prior to the failure to meet, there were a series of emergency meetings. Along with some lively but inconclusive dickering between the American and Russian ambassadors, these grand pow-wows featured the usual calls for all parties to exercise “utmost restraint” — never mind that Russian troops have been storming and digging into Georgian territory, not vice versa. Rotating members of the Council, such as Burkina Faso and Libya, allowed as how they would support whatever resolution might be reached by ”consensus.”

Consensus, of course, means that Russia, with its veto-wielding seat as one of the permanent five members of the Council — the others being China, France, the U.K. and the U.S. — must give its assent before the Security Council approve any resolution whatsoever. No surprise, then, that Monday’s news on the UN Security Council web site makes no mention of Georgia, though it does include such items as the donation by the UN Development Program of 500 bicycles “to help women pedal for peace in Uganda.” 

Where is that UN spirit that not so long ago was willing to raise absolute hell over the prospect of one country invading another? Where are the multilateral heirs of Kofi “illegal” Annan, now that there’s really something to raise hell about? 

Comment DiggDigg This Delicious del.icio.us Digg Print Digg PJM Home

3 Comments

1. srlucado:

“Where are the multilateral heirs of Kofi “illegal” Annan, now that there’s really something to raise hell about?”

Same place they always are: Waiting to find someone they can shake down for big dollars–without fear of retribution, of course.

Scott

Aug 19, 2008 - 4:35 am 2. Brian:

This is what ive saying to some friends of mine.Where the hell is the UN on this invasion of Georgia?Israel gets attacked by radical fighters in Gaza ,retaliates and takes out their leaders,and the UN is the first to lead the charge to condemn them.The russian invasion of georgia?Silence.Russian troops have now dug in in Georgian territory and havent moved.Time has come to remove the Russian threat.Its a violation of the cease-fire they have signed.Now the Ukraine is uneasy as Russia is giving passports to russians in Ukraine?Enough UN hypocrisy and time to get more people on watch at the UN.The UN was formed by US the people to prevent another world war and it is doing the opposite.UN founders would be so pissed right now.

Aug 19, 2008 - 2:51 pm 3. Steynian 228 « Free Mark Steyn!:

[...] CLAUDIA ROSETT: Russia, Georgia, the UN — and Where is Kofi Annan When He’s Really Needed? …. [...]

Aug 21, 2008 - 4:47 pm

Write a Comment

Name: (required, displayed)
Email: (required, not publicized)
URL: (optional, displayed)
remember personal info?
Comments: