Last week, while Burma’s military junta was busy at home beating and murdering peaceful democratic protesters, Burma’s foreign minister, U Nyan Win, a mouthpiece for the junta, took his country’s allotted turn in the lineup of speakers on the grand stage at the UN General Assembly opening in New York. He used his time in the UN spotlight to declare that “Normalcy has now returned to Myanmar.”
Revolted by this, I wrote a column for the Philadelphia Inquirer, noting that it does harm when the UN offers its main stage to such spokesmen for despotic governments. My comment was that while most Americans may regard the pronouncements of assorted tyrannies at the UN as merely so much irrelevant theater, these speeches made at the annual assembly in New York tend to get beamed back into the home countries and regions as evidence that despotic regimes such as Burma’s junta enjoy importance and respect on the world stage. That undermines democratic dissent, and undercuts any messages of support for democratization that America might be trying send.
So imagine the surprise to discover that one of the radio services busy beaming U Nyan Win’s Orwellian message of “normalcy” back into Burma was none other than our very own Voice of America. In a report dated Oct. 2, devoted almost entirely to parroting the bizarre pronouncements on the UN stage of Burma’s foreign minister, VOA simply fed back to its audience his perverse statements blaming Burma’s protests on “political opportunists” — along with his claims that foreign support for the protesters was “the ugly head of neo-colonialism,” and that Burma’s security personnel “exercised utmost restraint” until finally “they had to take action” to restore “normalcy.”
The VOA story goes on in this vein for six paragraphs, before making any specific mention of the junta’s murder of protesters — and then only by way of noting that Burma’s foreign minister “made no mention of the deaths or injuries caused by the security forces during the crackdown.” And only in the final paragraph is there a fleeting mention of actions taken by the U.S. administration to try to penalize members of Burma’s military government by way of economic sanctions.
It’s hard to see how Burma’s military rulers could get more p.r. mileage out of a news story if they’d paid for it themselves. Of course, this being VOA, it’s American taxpayers who paid for it. In theory, Americans bankroll VOA so this public news service can report and explain U.S. policy to listeners abroad. In practice, here we have VOA repeating and amplifying — for consumption abroad — the gross distortions of reality with which Burma’s government is now trying to justify its record of abusing and beggaring its own people, and arresting, beating and murdering Burmese who peacefully protest.
Iran’s repressive, terrorist-sponsoring regime got similarly deferential treatment from VOA in a report filed Oct. 3, about a press conference held at the UN by Iran’s foreign minister. It leads, uncritically, with this gem:
“Tehran’s top diplomat says his country is cooperating with the U.N. nuclear watchdog agency and wants a peaceful solution to the crisis. VOA’s Margaret Besheer has more from U.N. headquarters.”
Maybe it’s time to stop calling VOA the Voice of America, and start calling it the Voice of Anti-Americanism. And stop dunning American taxpayers to fund these outrages, which have been going on for years. If VOA wants to keep broadcasting stories like this, it’s way past time to yank U.S. taxpayer support, shut down the service, and if the Burmese military junta and the Iranian mullocracy want more of the same, let them pay for it themselves.


Digg This
del.icio.us

PJM Home


1 Comment
1. Joseph O'Connell:(Dear Editor:
I am sending along a letter from James K. Glassman, Chairman of the Broadcasting Board of Governors, in response to Claudia’s 10/8/07 piece about the Voice of America. Thanks in advance.
Joe O’Connell
Director
Office of Public Affairs)
To the Editor
PajamasMedia.com
It is hard for me to understand how Claudia Rosett could have written her piece in the Oct. 8 Pajamas.com website (“Voice of America? Megaphone for Iran and the Burmese Junta?”) about the coverage of the Burmese crisis by the Voice of America (VOA). I could not be more proud of the courageous work of VOA over the past two months on the Burma story.
Simply put, the Burmese regime is having a fit over the work of VOA (as well as that of Radio Free Asia (RFA)). VOA has just been called “assassins of the air,” and the junta is doing its best to stop people from listening, as reports by AP over the weekend confirm. Meanwhile, VOA and RFA have people who, at this very minute, are risking their lives to get information, including video, out of Burma. The Burmese have made it clear that reporters with both of our organizations (and the BBC) are to be regarded as spies and saboteurs and will be imprisoned and perhaps killed if caught.
Ms. Rosett wrote about a VOA piece on Burma and said that it reports an official statement “before making any specific mention of the junta’s murder of protesters.” The truth is that VOA and RFA have been THE main source of information for the Burmese people about just these murders from the time the protests began and well before. We have been properly praised by the Administration (Mrs. Bush did a sharp, exhorting interview on VOA just the other day) and cited by people like Sen. Joseph Lieberman for the work we have been doing.
Just as VOA did during the Cold War, we have been holding the hands of the Burmese people in a dark time, telling them what the rest of the world is doing to support them and providing the facts on the ground. As Newsweek.com said last week, “Everyone in the country…listens to the Burmese-language shortwave broadcasts from stations like the BBC, Radio Free Asia, Voice of American and…Democratic Voice of Burma.”
In order to establish and preserve the credibility in Burma that RFA has maintained for the past 10 years and VOA for the past 60, we do indeed broadcast straight news, even absurd government proclamations of the sort that Ms. Rosett cherry-picked. But our listeners have the context that Ms. Rosett obviously does not, having heard hundreds or thousands of hours of our broadcasts.
Last week, Than Lwin Htun, the head of VOA’s Burmese Service and himself a student leader during the 1988 uprising in Burma in which 3,000 died, testified before the Congressional Human Rights Caucus. He ended his testimony this way: “What we are doing at the Voice of America is to keep this communication going. We tell the world what is happening inside Burma. And we do our best to let all Burmese citizens know that they are not alone. We are proud to be able to empower the people of Burma with accurate news about how the world is responding to events inside Burma. We feel our reporting sustains the hope that they need to keep alive so that when their day finally arrives, they will prevail.”
Sincerely,
Oct 10, 2007 - 12:57 pmJames K. Glassman
Chairman
Broadcasting Board of Governors