It only takes one person.
If one person fights with all his might to tell the truth, (and today that person is Philippe Karsenty), if he or she risks everything to expose the Big Lie, takes on The Very Naked Emperor, then, one by one, others also start speaking out.
I have been writing about the doctored footage and staged photos that characterize the propaganda war against Israel and the Jews since 2001. Most recently, see HERE (Photos That Lie: Building the Case Against Israel, Article by Article, Day After Day), and HERE. (The Hoax That Launched the Al-Aqsa Intifada: Mainstream Media Complicity and Silence).
I have known the prominent Israeli academic, Dr. Marilyn Safir, of Haifa, for 36 years. She is an American-born left feminist psychologist who moderates a major Israeli feminist academic listserv group. I have written about her experiences of anti-Semitism in both The New Anti-Semitism and in The Death of Feminism. Nevertheless, Marilyn never disconnected from the international feminist movement for this reason–and I am not suggesting that she should have.
When the Kassam rockets literally began falling on her head in Haifa she invited me to come to Israel to talk about anti-Semitism in general and among intellectuals and progressives in particular. I agreed–but then, alas, could not go.
With her permission, I am sharing what she has just told me about her personal eye-witness experience of Palestinian faux-tography in the first Lebanon war (1981-1982). She writes:
Hi Phyllis :
In the first Lebanon War, just before I left for that feminist conference in Montreal, we saw two news reports on Israel TV. In one, the Israel news team followed a French film crew. The French media put several young children in a burnt out car and lit a fire on the far side of the car and then filmed the children in the “burning car” screaming and crying with the smoke and flames billowing in the background. Two days latter I saw this clip broadcast in Montreal. If I hadn’t seen them staging it, I would have believed these were kids who were directly attacked (by Israelis) and left to burn to death.
The other clip - was of the Israeli air force attacking a “hospital” with a big red cross on the roof. We could see that the “hospital” was actually a base of the PLO who were (engaged in) shooting from it. That, too, appeared on the news. Interestingly, the Lebanese Government took out a big paid ad stating that the (so-called) Hospital was PLO Headquarters and was headed by Arafat’s brother.
(The Montreal feminist ) conference was the one that the PLO tried to take over to pass anti- Israeli Resolutions - and that I more or less single handidly fought to prevent - successfully - I might add .
Marilyn
Thank you Marilyn. I wonder how many more such incidents people know about and when will they come forward? But as important: Will the mainstream Western and Arab language media ever cover this? Will the liberal blogosphere cover it? And, if not, what do we propose to do?
Dr. Richard Landes just told me that he dates what he has coined “Pallywood” (Palestinian hoax propaganda) back to the first Lebanon War. He has an excellent article about it HERE at his blogsite, AUGEAN STABLES.
Press HERE to listen to Fausta’s podcast featuring Richard Landes and Yaacov Ben Moshe.



Digg This
del.icio.us

PJM Home
The Death of Feminism: What’s Next in the Struggle for Women’s Freedom
Women and Madness
The New Anti-Semitism: The Current Crisis and What We Must Do About It
Woman’s Inhumanity to Woman
Women of the Wall: Claiming Sacred Ground at Judaism’s Holy Site
Letters to a Young Feminist
With Child: A Diary of Motherhood
Feminist Foremothers in Women’s Studies, Psychology, and Mental Health
Patriarchy: Notes of an Expert Witness
>Sacred Bond: The Legacy of Baby M
Mothers on Trial: The Battle for Children and Custody
About Men
Women, Money & Power


8 Comments
George Jochnowitz:I never heard the burning-car story before. It is an example of gross, deliberate dishonesty on the part of European reporters. Now that the Karsenty decision is beginning to make it into the news—a step at a time—this related case should be exhumed and publicized. It is quite relevant.
May 23, 2008 - 11:13 am Norman Simms:Phyllis
This is the kind of detail we need to collect and publish. All those interested in putting tgoether an anthology of documents and illustrations on the phenomenon of faux-tography used in anti-Israeli propaganda, please contact me, and we can begin to discuss how to get the book out.
Norman Simms
May 23, 2008 - 3:07 pm Nancy Kobrin, Ph.D.:Outrigger Publishers
nsimms@waikato.ac.nz
Phyllis you are right once again. Ayaan Hirsi Ali wrote that jihad is not just about ideology and its words but it is a jihad of imagery. Once again the Palestinians show us how much they hate their own children that they would put them in a burning car and terrify them. This week in Minnesota the principal of the Tarik Ibn Ziad Academy (Tiza), a publicly funded day school lead his students outside to assault a television camera man. It can’t get much more literal than that — that they would attack a person who makes images but not to their liking and would use their own children as human shields. They endlessly and brutally manipulate their own children rendering them terrified. There ought to be an international law. . .
May 23, 2008 - 8:14 pm Dr S McCosker:Dear Dr Chesler - I read Dr Landes. Interesting that he traces it back to the First Lebanon War. Back in the early 80s I learnt to read (not speak, but read) French. This meant that I was able to read Jacques Ellul’s ‘Un Chretien Pour Israel’ [1986] (which has never been translated into English). A whole, long section of that book deals with ‘Propaganda’: that is, with the Arab/Muslim (and, at that time, Soviet also) propaganda against Israel. Ellul covered a lot of the same ground as Landes, and his conclusions were the same - that the ‘Palestinian’ Arab Muslims, and the Islamosphere in general, with their Useful Idiots and fellow travellers in the French media to boot, were…Big Liars on a par with Goebbels; that there was a vast, well-funded, and clever propaganda war going on, against Israel and the Jews; and he ALSO gave it as his professional opinion that Israel was ‘useless at propaganda’, that the Jews were, in general, very honest, i.e. that the charge that there was an Israeli or Jewish propaganda going on, was completely nonsensical. That book (especially as I knew already that Ellul as a sociologist had professionally deconstructed - and that he despised - propaganda of every kind), transformed the way I viewed the Israel -’palestine’ conflict. It immunised me against the Arab Muslim propaganda, very very effectively. Landes’ analysis, and Safir’s testimony, confirms Ellul’s conclusions from 20 years ago.
May 24, 2008 - 1:59 am Alcibiades:Sounds like one of the techniques taught to Arafat by his KGB handlers. I bet Ion Pacepa would know for sure.
May 24, 2008 - 11:57 am Manny:In her recent book “Because they hate”, Christian Lebanese US journalist Brigitte Gabriel mentions the disinformation from the Palestinians and their friends during the Lebanon war.
Jun 11, 2008 - 7:10 pm