
I admit it: The debate bored me. I even nodded off–something I never do while on duty. And yet: This election has taken up too much space. It has been a cross between a long running soap opera and a personality contest, a spectacle instead of a solution–spectacle as the solution.
But Governor Sarah Palin is truly an exemplary “Mrs. Smith goes to Washington.” She is a genuine provincial outsider and this is part of her considerable charm. She is potentially Karen Silkwood and Norma Jean Rae and she held her own “real well” against consummate insider Senator Joe Biden who kept calling her “Governor” even as he continuously referred to her Presidential running-mate as “John.” (Senator McCain to you mister).
The contrast was clear as is the choice. More smooth talking Beltway politicians or a down home “little lady” politician. More government regulations (although God knows, Wall Street needs some brakes and even Palin agreed with Biden on this one)–versus less government and lower taxes; the importance of stopping a nuclear and Hate Israel Iran; the nature of patriotism; a re-definition of what qualifies someone to hold high public office.
Folks: While Biden demonstrated restraint, his capacity for anger simmered just below the surface and seems every bit as great as that reputed to McCain. He got in lots of details, lots of name dropping, lots of bills, issues, lots of history happened on his watch and he made sure we knew it. Biden only got angry and emotional when he feared that Palin had appealed as a mother to other mothers and then, with a voice quivering with emotion, he defended the “humanity” of single fathers who can function just as mothers can and which is something that he himself did.
If pressed, I’d have to say that Palin “aced” this one and not because she is as experienced as Joe Biden, (whose record is, I think, long and largely admirable), and not because she can talk about learning something from House Speaker Mike Mansfield–that’s Biden’s forte–but because a) she did better than we expected her to do–we had lower expectations for her; b) she was also able to demonstrate a gut and unflappable command of complicated issues; c) she represented a different approach and she stuck to her metaphoric guns. In her view, raising taxes and paying them is not “patriotic.” Sending your troops into harms way to protect America’s freedoms is “patriotic” as is developing independent energy so that America does not continue to fund countries that hate America. Palin supports what is happening now in Iraq and views it as where America is fighting Al-Qaeda. Biden does not. In her words, directed to Biden she said: “Your solution is a white flag of surrender.”
God knows what the fact checkers will reveal by morning, if not any minute,about whether McCain or Obama did or did not vote for particular resolutions and what their votes or failures to vote really signify.
Did anyone notice that Palin, after her strong statement of support for Israel, said that America would move its Embassy to Jerusalem? Assuming the two state solution both she and Biden said they favored still meant that Israelis would control an undivided Jerusalem, her statement was a revelation.
Did anyone notice that both candidates favor only limited civil rights for same sex couples? And that neither mentioned the word “woman,” not even once, (except for Biden’s pronouncing the Violence Against Women Act but very quickly)?
I am “tired, and I gotta got to bed, I had a coupla drinks and they went right to my head”….but tomorrow, stay tuned for some thoughts about why I’m not sure that Obama is really your typical African-American and what I think about McCain’s choice of a woman–this particular woman–for his Vice-Presidential running mate.
PLEASE NOTE: The blogosphere is weighing in brilliantly on the Great Debate. Biden was not factual, Palin provided her own contrast and corrective to the mainstream media’s mischeivous mischaracterization. Read Fausta, Epamonidas and SerandEZ & Friends.





PJM Home
Woman's Inhumanity to Woman
The Death of Feminism: What’s Next in the Struggle for Women’s Freedom
Women and Madness
The New Anti-Semitism: The Current Crisis and What We Must Do About It
Woman’s Inhumanity to Woman
Women of the Wall: Claiming Sacred Ground at Judaism’s Holy Site
Letters to a Young Feminist
With Child: A Diary of Motherhood
Feminist Foremothers in Women’s Studies, Psychology, and Mental Health
Patriarchy: Notes of an Expert Witness
Sacred Bond: The Legacy of Baby M
Mothers on Trial: The Battle for Children and Custody
About Men
Women, Money & Power

12 Comments
1. Helena Handbasket:Yes. She did better than expected and we did have lower expectations.
But, that is not the same as having no expectations.
By any rational standard, Palin was under truly enormous pressure. She had to perform and, had she bombed, the entire campaign would have gone down the drain.
She came through with flying colors and gave what was easily the best debate performance to date - by any of the four candidates.
It was a fantastic example of grace under astounding pressure. Her ability to perform well under that degree of stress will put her permanently on the national political map.
Oct 3, 2008 - 4:42 am 2. Fausta:Not so much Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, more The Farmer’s Daughter
Oct 3, 2008 - 5:29 am 3. epaminondas:Funny you should mention FRANK CAPRA
Oct 3, 2008 - 5:49 am 4. Fausta’s Blog » Blog Archive » Biden’s big lie, and his 13 other lies:[...] posted on Palin as Mrs. Smith Goes to Washington, but I see it more of The Farmer’s Daughter’s story line. Not from the romantic story [...]
Oct 3, 2008 - 5:50 am 5. wassom:As I sat down to watch Sarah, as most people were, the main stream media, includeded. You could feel the tension through the screen. The blood rushing, heart pounding pressure that was on this extraordinary lady.
Oct 3, 2008 - 6:53 am 6. B Dubya:She handled it beautifully, with grace and dignity.
He partriotism shewed through, and her strength of character. The character the main stream media would like to snuff out and wish she would just go away!
We need strong, indecisive, leadership, with by someone with a love for America, a respect for our troops, and moral character. Someone that is not afraid of not being “politically correct”. Praise God he has raised up such a person for such times as these!
The elephant in the room for the Democrats is the GSE’s, which have been used to game the free market, with lot’s of congressional participation in both the gaming and the corruption aspects.
Oct 3, 2008 - 8:30 am 7. Fern Sidman:Every time government games the market, it kills the market.
Government needs to set up and enforce rules for the real players; level paying field, honesty, with penalties for the insiders and crooks that violate the market rules that are tough enough to deter the squeamish at least.
As long as Fannie and Freddie have Barney Frank, Chris Dodds, and yes, Joe Biden in their corner, you will never see that black hole filled.
By the way, I thought Sarah did well last night. I just wish she had gone after the Democratic ticket (both Fannie and Freddie contribution takers) for their role in the debacle.
She may yet.
One of her trademark debating techniques is to basically ignore the current stupid or trick question and talk about something the audience really wants to hear. I’d like to hear someone call Biden on his someletely wrong interpretation of Article 1 and Roe V Wade, among other things. I’d like the Republican ticket to call Obama on his continued assaults on protected 1st Ammandmend speech (the Obamabot swarms and the threatening tactics that coopt State law enforecement) in a debate forum to give him a chance to squirm in public.
So glad that you are one of the only bloggers who caught the statement made by Gov. Palin about the US moving its embassy to Jerusalem. That’s an extremely powerful and important statement, considering the fact that no other previous administration would even entertain the notion as it was way too politically charged. The fact that Gov Palin said this speaks volumes about the intent of a McCain-Palin administration. Perhap, under their leadership, the State Department will actually be composed of those with the courage to stand up to Arab pressure.
Oct 3, 2008 - 9:21 am 8. Fern Sidman:So glad that you were one of the very few bloggers who caught the comment that Gov Palin made regarding the intent of a McCain-Palin administration to move the US Embassy to Jerusalem. It’s quite clear that speaks volumes regarding the intent of their Middle East policy.
I applaud Sen McCain and Gov Palin for having the courage to speak about this, considering the fact that no other administration would even seriously entertain the notion of publicly calling for a undivided “Jewish” Jerusalem.
One can only wonder what a State Department under their leadership would look like. Perhaps, for the first time ever it will actually be composed of those who are not apologists for Arab oil interests
Oct 3, 2008 - 9:41 am 9. Flowerchild2:And who lowered her expectations??? She did not lower them. The media and the hate mongers on the left did that. She stated she will not preach to us or try to convert us; she stated that she has a best friend from childhood who is gay? She has indicated she will do nothing to harm them. We all can’t think alike. So she thinks being gay is a choice. A lot of people think that; and we really don’t know because we have not totally resolved the nature/nurture question. We have enough stuffed shirts in WA; we have enough people manipulating the system, and enough of career politicians. I have anyway. Go PALIN!!
Oct 3, 2008 - 10:10 am 10. ic:“She is a genuine provincial outsider …”
Darn! All this time we were told by the MSM that Biden was the “outsider” for communting to DC from his Delaware home.
Oct 3, 2008 - 11:08 am 11. ic:“He got in lots of details, lots of name dropping, lots of bills, issues, lots of history happened on his watch and he made sure we knew it.” But not sure enough to notice that most of his cited “facts” were bogus, made up by him on the spot to score points.
To paraphrase Churchill: Plagiarist Biden would say: I know facts are good to me, I make them up.
Oct 3, 2008 - 11:17 am 12. Judy, NYC:i laughed out loud when palin cornered biden and got him (the 36 year politico) to admit “neither i nor barak obama favor gay marriage”. especially funny was the obama sticker. barry would never have the guts to say outright what he thinks about anything. i am not even sure that he actually does think about anything. ironically, the guy is a gw bush clone. sarah palin was wonderful. great woman. very stand up person. forthright. the jerusalem remark and the strong unequivocal stance for isreal also cornered biden into stating his support for isreal, without ambivalence. she is really something. i can readily imagine palin getting the largest tax revenue in history from those oil moguls. she would be marvelous with bad guys from anywhere in the world. it sealed the deal for me. i can’t stand barry obama, it fills me with disgust every time i have to hear his lies and constant oily slipping around on issues, and inability or unwillingness to be clear. biden, however, did say that he would sit next to obama in every meeting, an assistant president as it were (biden even had to state that he, himself would not be president). jeez. palin’s energy and intelligence is so evident and she is so willing to go the distance. later, when asked about the withdrawal from michigan, palin said she and “todd” would go to michigan themselves and talk to the factory workers and home owners, because they have gone through this experience. i like her a lot. palin is a real populist, not a make-believe one. i could stand a palin presidency. very easily.
Oct 3, 2008 - 5:44 pm