Rep. Chris Cannon–who has a 96 score (out of 100) by the American Conservative Union–was beaten in a primary challenge today in Utah’s thrid congressional district.
His challenger, Jason Chaffetz, said Rep. Cannon wasn’t conservative enough.
As the nominee in this heavily Republican district, Chaffetz is expected to easily win election in November.
Chaffetz wants to shutter the Department of Education and return education policy to the states, to deny the children of illegal immigrants automatic citizenship and return the GOP to “its core conservative principles.”
What does this mean? Two things immediately spring to mind:
The Republican brand is not dead. The only landslide defeat the party has endured in the last 30 years was the 2006 congressional elections. And the White House party usually loses the sixth-year midterms. Indeed, the frustration of the conservative base with the GOP may be that the party is not conservative enough.
And while two primaries hardly make a trend, the Cannon-Chaffetz race comes after Maryland liberal Republican Rep. Wayne Gilchrest was defeated by a conservative candidate.
Finally, I had lunch the other day with a recently retired Republican congressman. He had a reputation as a staunch conservative. Gas prices came up. I suggested that the federal tax get suspended not for two months as McCain proposes but until oil falls to $60/barrel–roughly where it was when the Democrats came into office in November 2006. I added that federal highway funds should be conditioned on states also suspending their fuel taxes.
He was horrified. I know gas prices are making people angry, he said, but the government needs the revenue…
Whatever. The people need the revenue. This is why the conservative base is unhappy. The rebels all took jobs with the palace guard. That’s what Chaffetz’s victory means.



Digg This
del.icio.us

PJM Home
Disinformation : 22 Media Myths That Undermine the War on Terror
Shadow War: The Untold Story of How Bush Is Winning the War on Terror
The Myth of Market Share: Why Market Share Is the Fool’s Gold of Business

2 Comments
David Thomson:Republicans should normally be united in the general election. Their candidates, however “moderate,” are usually more conservative than their Democratic Party opponents. It is during the primaries when the house cleaning should occur. This sort of behavior should be encouraged.
Jun 26, 2008 - 9:32 am j green:The above comment can be rephrased as follows:
The GOP candidate is holding a gun to your head on a couple of issues (maybe terrorism, Iran, or gay marriage) so you, conservative lap dog, must vote for the Maverick, lest Barry Hussein will put the American way-of-life in jeapardy.
The point is well-taken, and the blog topic also illustrates “primary season house cleaning, but the GOP has to be careful–you can’t out-liberal a liberal. The GOP is jeapardizing its base big time by continuing to play with guns
I, for one, made my protest vote for Huckabee in the VA primary, and am voting the way all good hostages must vote.
Jun 27, 2008 - 5:52 pm