Perhaps the most ravishing musical experience of my life was listening to Simone Dinnerstein play Bach’s Goldberg Variations’s at the home of a friend in Manhattan last autumn. In the weeks before the performance, I had listened several times to a CD of Dinnerstein’s remarkable 2007 interpretation of the work, but hearing her en famille, as it were, in the intimate setting of a living room with a dozen friends dramatically heightened the experience.
But it was the performance as well as the setting that made the evening so special. Hitherto my gold standard for renditions of this majestic piece of music was Glenn Gould’s 1955 recording. (Gould made a second recording shortly before his death, age fifty, in the early 1980s.) I especially admired the astringent clarity and architecture of Gould’s playing. Gould burrowed deep into the structure of Bach’s music, revealing its bones and sinews. His astonishing technical command allowed him to exhibit latent conversations within the music, rhythmic and emotional exfoliations that elaborated themselves with pristine lucidity, like crystals forming and dissolving in an ice-cold, light-inflected mountain stream.
Dinnerstein’s Bach is a warmer, but no less lucid creature. Like Gould, Dinnerstein commands a breathtaking technical mastery. And like him, she has made the music her own. She does not simply play the Goldbergs. She inhabits them, moving through its 30 variations like the rising sun through the rooms of a palace. Each chamber is suddenly illuminated and its distinctive character gradually revealed as the light lingers in loving dialogue with the soul’s furniture. And just as each day’s light has its own discoveries and omissions, so it was with Dinnerstein’s performances of the Goldbergs. Anyone who had heard the CD of her performing the work would have instantly recognized her stamp on the performance that evening. But what was remarkable was how distinctive each rendition was: like a familiar landscape seen at noon and then again an hour before dusk.
Dinnerstein is a master of rubato–listen, for example, to the way she coaxes Variation 4 to unfold itself before us–but also she handles the presto passages with breathtaking aplomb: her joyful unpacking of Variation 14 is a case in point. Dinnerstein’s Bach is perhaps less cerebral than Gould’s, but no less intelligent. There is an amplitude to her convocations that Gould’s austerity wouldn’t countenance.
But I revisit Dinnerstein’s Goldbergs merely as a prelude to mentioning her performance yesterday at the Walter Reade Theater at Lincoln Center in New York. Her late-morning concert, part of the Center’s Great Performers series, included two preludes and fugues (numbers 9 in E-major and 3 in C-sharp-major) from book II of the Well-tempered Clavier, Beethoven’s Sonata 13 in E-flat major, and Eine Kleine Mitternachtmusik, a curious, amusing and bemusing work by the contemporary American composer George Crumb. As an encore, Dinnerstein played the lovely A-major intermezzo from Brahms’s opus 118 suite of piano pieces.
It was a memorable occasion. Dinnerstein’s signature combination of technical command and patient lusciousness informed every moment. Her playing is less idiosyncratic than Gould’s, but no less distinctive. Her taste–witness the Crumb–ranges widely, yet there is a clarifying purity to her playing that inoculates it against mannerism. Her personality touches and enlivens all she plays, but one always feels that the focus is on the music, not the music maker. This is true artistry, a sort of musical midwifery in which the point is not the performer but the thing performed. I hope you’ll have an opportunity to hear her (her concert schedule is posted here). You’ll certainly be hearing a lot more about her.





PJM Home
The New Criterion
The Rape of the Masters: How Political Correctness Sabotages Art
Lives of the Mind: The Use and Abuse of Intelligence from Hegel to Wodehouse
Art’s Prospect: The Challenge of Tradition in an Age of Celebrity
Experiments Against Reality: The Fate of Culture in the Postmodern Age
Tenured Radicals, NEW, EXPANDED EDITION FALL 2008! How Politics has Corrupted our Higher Education
Counterpoints: 25 Years of The New Criterion on Culture and the Arts
The Long March: How the Cultural Revolution of the 1960s Changed America
Against the Idols of the Age
Lengthened Shadows: America and Its Institutions in the Twenty-First Century
The Survival of Culture: Permanent Values in a Virtual Age
Physics and Politics, by Walter Bagehot, edited with an
Introduction by Roger Kimball
Pajamas Media appreciates your comments that abide by the following guidelines:
1. Avoid profanities or foul language unless it is contained in a necessary quote or is relevant to the comment.
2. Stay on topic.
3. Disagree, but avoid ad hominem attacks.
4. Threats are treated seriously and reported to law enforcement.
5. Spam and advertising are not permitted in the comments area.
The clause regarding "hate speech" has been deleted because readers criticized it as being too loosely defined. We agreed.
These guidelines are very general and cannot cover every possible situation. Please don't assume that Pajamas Media management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment. We reserve the right to filter or delete comments or to deny posting privileges entirely at our discretion. If you feel your comment was filtered inappropriately, please email us at story@pajamasmedia.com.
8 Comments
1. Tim:Roger,
Apologies for the off-topic post, but can you write a sentence or two on what you thing of the artist Charles Browning? His parodies of the Hudson River School seem, um, a bit unserious to me — too much mockery of his subjects, and there seems to be nothing left after you get past the cynicism. Any comments?
Tim
May 5, 2008 - 5:20 pm 2. Dex Quire:Roger, Ahem. I don’t usually associate your writing with purple prose but here…what happened? I think my soul’s toe got stubbed on my soul’s furniture (the ottoman) somewhere in the middle of your article. I was surprised to see one of those two-fisted subject sentences (”What was remarkable was..”). Wouldn’t simple exclamation do?
That said, I know that writing about music is like writing about heaven: it’s hard. And I do look forward to hearing the heavenly Ms., Dinnerstein – thanks.
May 6, 2008 - 7:57 am 3. extensis mask pro crack:DQ
extensis mask pro crack extensis mask pro crack [link=http://kendallehto.iespana.es/roladomdo.html]extensis mask pro crack[/link]
Sep 21, 2008 - 10:57 am 4. medical license board ca:medical license board ca medical license board ca [link=http://topkickerpoker.com/dev/resources/templates_c/img/text-1016.htm]medical license board ca[/link]
Nov 13, 2008 - 1:38 pm 5. quicktime pro crack mac:quicktime pro crack mac quicktime pro crack mac [link=http://furmanka.com/list/attachments/files/page1822.html]quicktime pro crack mac[/link]
Nov 13, 2008 - 1:41 pm 6. summer employment college student:summer employment college student summer employment college student [link=http://lachiacn.ifrance.com/page824.html]summer employment college student[/link]
Dec 10, 2008 - 9:15 am 7. life video to go:life video to go life video to go [link=http://crbaldwi.interfree.it/1047119009/]life video to go[/link]
Dec 10, 2008 - 9:15 am 8. Roger’s Rules » Another musical interlude:[...] perform at the Quick Center for the Arts at Fairfield University in Fairfield, CT. I’ve written about Dinnerstein in this space before. She is an extraordinary musician. As I said in that earlier posting, hearing [...]
Feb 28, 2009 - 11:15 am